Why We Cry: Hot Tears, Cold Tears and Emotional Release

I've cried in my kitchen holding a half-burnt piece of toast, which is a fairly embarrassing object to be holding while your body decides it's time to have a moment. I don't think the tears were really about the toast, although it was my last piece, so let's give the toast at least a little credit. My chest felt tight, my eyes had their own agenda, and there I was trying to work out how breakfast had become an emotional event when I hadn't even managed to make it properly.

That's the part of crying that gets me, how we can know what we're feeling and still have absolutely no control over the way it comes out of our faces. My nose runs, my throat does that awful hiccup thing, and sometimes I get so hot that you'd think the room had changed temperature just to participate. Then there are the tears that arrive during a movie or a commercial, when nobody in my actual life is in danger and I'm perfectly aware that someone wrote this whole thing to make me cry. I lost it within the first fifteen minutes of Finding Nemo, and I still think Pixar could've given us a slightly gentler introduction to that family.

Your Eyes Were Making Tears Before Anything Upset You

We tend to notice tears once they're running down our cheeks, but our eyes have been using them all day, including during the very boring stretches when nothing remotely emotional is happening. A thin tear film spreads over the front of the eye when we blink, helping keep that surface comfortable, protected, and smooth enough for clear vision. The National Eye Institute describes an oily outer layer that slows evaporation, a watery middle layer that wets and nourishes the surface, and an inner mucus layer that helps the film stay in place. There's a surprising amount of organization going into something most of us only acknowledge when a contact lens starts feeling personally offended.

Those everyday maintenance tears are called basal tears, while reflex tears increase in response to things that irritate the eye, such as smoke or the chemicals released when we cut an onion. Neither requires a meaningful childhood memory or an upsetting phone call; the eye is responding to an immediate problem on its surface. This is why I can be crying over a cutting board while feeling completely fine about my life, apart from the fact that dinner now involves wiping my face with my shoulder. I could buy the onions already chopped, but I don't like how they dry out, so apparently I've decided that a little vegetable-related suffering is part of the arrangement.

AI-generated editorial illustration of a cut onion and slices on a wooden kitchen board beside a resting knife, illustrating a common trigger for reflex tears.

Then a Feeling Gets Involved

Emotional tears belong to the third category, and the trigger can be sadness, anger, relief, tenderness, or the kind of happiness that suddenly feels too big for a normal smile. The tear glands are responding to signals involving the brain and autonomic nervous system rather than simply trying to wash away an irritant. Crying can also bring changes in breathing, facial muscles, and sound, which explains why the experience can feel so much bigger than a few drops of water. Somewhere between recognizing that we're upset and trying to say we're fine, our whole face has become involved in the conversation.

I still think about that commercial where an older man gives a little boy soup for his sick mother, and the boy later becomes a doctor who helps him in return. Even describing the plot feels like I'm handing over the instructions for getting me to cry, because kindness coming back around like that gets me every time. It also makes the usual assumption that tears mean sadness feel a little inadequate. We can cry because something hurts, because something finally feels safe, or because somebody did something so decent that we'd like to live in that version of the world for a while.

The Stress-Hormone Story Needs Some Untangling

One explanation that gets passed around is that emotional tears flush stress hormones and toxins out of the body, leaving us calmer because we've physically drained the bad stuff through our eyes. I can see why that idea catches on, especially when a hard cry really does leave you feeling lighter, but the feeling doesn't establish the mechanism. Researchers have investigated differences in tear composition, and hormones and proteins are part of the broader discussion, yet finding a substance in tears doesn't show that losing that small amount is what makes us feel better. A research review by Asmir Gračanin and colleagues specifically questions the idea that relief comes from clearing stress hormones out through tears.

The same care applies to oxytocin, which often gets introduced as the cuddle hormone before being given responsibility for practically every nice feeling we have. Researchers have proposed roles for oxytocin and other biological systems in crying and comfort, but that doesn't give us a confirmed recipe for emotional tears or a guarantee that every cry releases a soothing chemical cocktail. I love a cuddle, and my husband absolutely deserves his mention here, but I don't need to pretend we've measured a hormone change to explain why being held by someone I trust can feel good. The comfort is real even when the explanation takes a little longer to sort out.

Why a Good Cry Can Take a While to Feel Good

In a 2015 study, researchers measured people's mood before an emotional film, immediately afterward, and again twenty and ninety minutes later. The participants who cried felt worse just after the film, then recovered over time and reported a better mood at the final measurement than they'd reported before it. That delayed change helps explain why someone can remember a cry as helpful while still feeling absolutely dreadful in the middle of it. The study was small and people weren't randomly assigned to produce tears, so it can't establish that crying itself caused the improvement or that everybody will follow the same timetable.

That last part matters when the phrase “have a good cry” starts sounding like an instruction we can fail at. Sometimes I've felt my breathing settle and my jaw loosen afterward, while at other times the thing that upset me has still been sitting right there, completely unimpressed by all the effort my face just made. Researchers are still working out how the act of crying, the passage of time, changes in the situation, and comfort from other people fit together. If relief doesn't arrive, adding a second problem about whether you cried correctly seems like a particularly unhelpful use of an already difficult afternoon.

AI-generated editorial illustration of a green eye and a tear on an adult’s cheek; a conceptual image, not a photograph of the author.

When Grief Leaves Your Whole Face Sore

After my trauma, I cried so much that the skin over my eyelids peeled for months, and it burned when I blinked even though the tears kept coming. My dermatologist was kind, but we didn't find the simple fix I wanted, which made an already painful stretch feel even more exhausting. I'm sharing that as something that happened to me, because crying can have a very physical side that gets lost when we describe it only in lovely language about release. Sometimes your face hurts and you're tired of washing it, and you don't particularly want a beautiful interpretation of any of it.

Grief also doesn't follow a sensible schedule, and the amount someone cries won't tell us how much they've loved or how much they're hurting. I understand the temptation to describe held-back tears as something that will eventually poison us, because keeping everything contained can feel awful, but that turns a complicated experience into another frightening rule. Someone may cry constantly, cry privately, feel numb, or find that tears simply won't come, and none of those responses gives us a complete account of what they're carrying. We can make room for feelings without insisting that every person has to express them through wet cheeks.

Why Tears Can Feel Hot, Cold, or Stingy

My face can get red and hot when I cry, and the tears sometimes feel as though they're joining in, but I wouldn't use their temperature to identify the emotion behind them. Warmth and stinging are different sensations, and neither comes with a reliable label saying grief, nostalgia, or joy. Burning can involve dry eye, irritation, allergies, or inflamed eyelids, which is a much less romantic explanation than the idea that heartbreak produces hotter water. Once you've spent a while wiping and rubbing an already sensitive area, the skin around your eyes may be having its own miserable experience alongside the feeling that started all of this.

There's an ordinary plumbing explanation for the runny nose, too, because tears drain through small openings near the inner corners of the eyes and travel down toward the nose. When there's a lot of fluid, some spills onto the cheeks while the drainage route is still doing its job, giving us the delightful combination of crying and needing to blow our noses. The biology is interesting, but persistent burning, eye pain, or a change in vision deserves an eye professional's attention rather than an emotional explanation. Having a difficult week doesn't make every uncomfortable thing happening to your eyes part of the same story.

Being Tired and Being Near Your Period Can Join In

I've certainly had moments when the explanation for being unusually tearful becomes a little clearer once I realize my period is close, and then I have to reconsider the seriousness of whatever set me off. Crying spells and mood changes can be part of premenstrual symptoms, although the timing and intensity vary, and nobody gets to dismiss a real concern just because a menstrual cycle happens to be involved. I find that distinction useful because knowing there's another influence on how strongly I feel something doesn't mean the thing itself has stopped mattering. It means there may be several contributors to a reaction that looked, from the outside, as though it came from nowhere.

Sleep belongs in that conversation as well, since research has linked sleep loss with changes in how we respond to emotional material. That doesn't mean every tired person cries or that we can diagnose a sleepless night by looking at someone's face, but it makes sense to consider the condition we're in alongside the event we're reacting to. A burnt piece of toast lands differently when you already feel worn down, even if you can't neatly separate the influence of every worry, disappointment, and unfinished task. When changes around your period are severe or keep disrupting daily life, they're worth discussing with a clinician rather than treating them as something you're supposed to tolerate indefinitely.

What About the Dog Looking Back at Us?

It's very easy to look at an animal we love and recognize something familiar in its expression, especially when we're already feeling tender ourselves. Animals produce tears to protect their eyes, and an interesting 2022 study found that dogs' tear volume increased after reuniting with their owners compared with a familiar person who wasn't their owner. Applying an oxytocin solution to the eyes also increased tear volume, giving the researchers a possible biological connection to investigate. That's a finding about tear production in a particular situation, so it doesn't establish that a dog sheds tears of grief in the same way we do or tell us exactly what that dog is experiencing.

I like having room for both the finding and the uncertainty, because loving an animal doesn't require us to make its inner life identical to ours. We can notice changes in behavior, offer care, and take distress seriously without deciding that every watery eye is a heartbreak we can translate. The distinction becomes especially useful when a physical eye problem could be involved, since assuming sadness might distract us from something that needs a veterinarian. The dog still gets the affection, which I suspect is the part of this discussion the dog would be most interested in anyway.

The Extra Work of Feeling Embarrassed About It

I was one of the girls who got called too emotional and too dramatic, and that sort of response can make you start apologizing before you've even figured out what upset you. Boys are often handed their own version of the problem, where being tough is supposed to mean nobody ever sees a tear, and then we're all left trying to have ordinary feelings while managing somebody else's opinion of them. I don't want to replace those old expectations with a new requirement that everyone should cry freely in every room. Sometimes we need privacy, sometimes we need to finish the conversation later, and sometimes the person standing in front of us hasn't earned access to the vulnerable part of it.

What I do want is a little less judgment about the fact that the reaction happened, especially when it's inconvenient or doesn't look the way someone expects. Tears don't automatically make a person right in an argument, but they don't make that person's point less worth hearing either. We can give each other time to settle, listen to what's actually being said, and return to the problem without making composure the price of admission. I'd much rather have that conversation than spend it debating whether someone should've been able to keep their eyes dry.

AI-generated editorial concept of one adult resting a hand on another’s hand on a sofa beside tissues and a mug, illustrating comfort and support.

Sometimes the Useful Part Is Who Stays With You

A large study involving participants in forty-one countries found that visible tears increased people's stated willingness to offer support when they looked at faces. That's evidence about responses to images, rather than a promise about what any particular person will do in a real, messy moment, but it gives researchers one way to examine the social side of crying. Our tears can help other people recognize that something matters or that we need care, even when we're having trouble getting the words out. It makes me think about how much can happen in the space between noticing someone is upset and deciding whether to give them a little kindness.

For me, being close to my husband can be part of that comfort, and I remain very much in favor of cuddling when everybody involved wants to cuddle. Somebody else might want a glass of water, a little space, or help with the actual problem that started the tears, so asking what would help seems more useful than launching straight into a pep talk. After a hard cry, sobbing, tense muscles, and the emotional strain can leave us feeling worn out, but we don't need to assume we've burned through our blood sugar or completed a workout to take that tiredness seriously. Sometimes you need a break becuase you've had a difficult time, and that seems like enough of a reason.

I still find it strange that an eye needs fluid to see clearly and also ends up spilling it when a feeling gets too big, as though two entirely different parts of being alive have agreed to share some equipment. Knowing a little more about the equipment hasn't made the toast story less ridiculous or made me immune to a well-timed act of kindness in a commercial. It has made me less interested in judging the tears, though, and a little more interested in what might help the person having them. If that's me, I can put the toast down, let my face do whatever it's doing, and give myself a minute before deciding what the rest of the morning needs.

After a good cry, I usually notice that my face feels tight and the room’s gotten dark. I’d wash my face and make a mug of peppermint tea. By the time it’s cool enough to drink, at least I’ve done something kind for myself.

Related Reads from the Archive

Sources

Michele Edington (formerly Michele Gargiulo)

Certified Sommelier, Certified Specialist of Wine, WSET Diploma student, writer & storyteller. I blend wine, science & curiosity to help you see the world as strange and beautiful as it truly is.

https://www.michelegargiulo.com/bio-page
Previous
Previous

Are Humans Made of Stardust? The Elements Inside You

Next
Next

Nightmare Poetry