The Rise and Fall of Lard in American Cooking

I love how an ingredient can sit in a kitchen for generations without attracting much attention, then somehow become the subject of an enormous argument. Lard is a particularly good example, because we're talking about rendered pig fat, something that can help make a lovely pie crust, and yet the conversation around it can very quickly involve industrial food, your grandmother, heart disease, farming, and whether everybody has been lied to. That's a considerable amount of responsibility for something you're measuring into a bowl. I'm interested in how it acquired all that baggage, especially because the story gets much stranger when you look at the advertising that helped Americans replace it.

There really was a time when lard had a much more ordinary place in American cooking, and vegetable shortening really did change the competition. But the familiar version, where everybody loved lard until one company frightened us away from it and now we're finally learning the truth, leaves out an awful lot. Some cooks never stopped using it, some had good reasons to choose something else, and an ingredient can work beautifully in pastry without becoming a prescription for better health. I think the actual history is considerably more interesting than giving the pig a comeback tour and pretending the rest of the kitchen was a mistake.

First, What Exactly Is Lard?

Lard is pork fat separated from much of the surrounding tissue through rendering. Heating allows the fat to become liquid, while water is driven off and solid material can be separated out. Once cooled, the result can be pale and soft, although the flavor and texture depend on the material and how it's processed. Leaf lard comes from the internal fat associated with the kidney area, rather than from a special breed of pig that grows little fatty leaves, which is where my brain briefly wanted to go. Back fat and other pork trimmings can also be rendered, so the word lard doesn't describe one completely identical product.

That matters when we're talking about baking. A mild lard is a very different proposition from a fat with a pronounced cooked-pork flavor, especially if the eventual destination is an apple pie. Bacon drippings are pork fat too, but they've picked up the flavor of cured, often smoked bacon and whatever happened in the pan. I wouldn't treat those as interchangeable with a mild baking lard just because they came from the same animal. There's room for a savory crust, of course, but I'd like the bacon to have been invited. An unexpected pork announcement in the middle of dessert seems like something the cook should know about in advance.

Lard Was Already a Household Ingredient and a Business

A. W. Fulton's 1900 book Home Pork Making describes farm processing, commercial packing, different grades of lard, and the care involved in producing it. It even separates a whole chapter for making lard, which tells you this wasn't simply a matter of collecting whatever grease happened to be left over. The fat had uses, a market, and distinctions people thought were worth understanding. I find that detail useful because it's easy to turn the past into one enormous farmhouse where everybody made everything from scratch, when the same book is already discussing large packing establishments and the relationship between home production and commercial food.

And then there's the introduction, which worries that farm pork making is becoming a lost skill. The book was published in 1900, before Crisco arrived. Apparently we've been standing in kitchens worrying that nobody knows how to do anything properly anymore for quite a while. That doesn't mean skills can't be lost or that changing food systems don't matter, but it does make me smile at how familiar the complaint sounds. We don't have to invent a perfect earlier kitchen to understand why a usable supply of cooking fat mattered, especially when it came from an animal a household or butcher was already processing.

AI-generated editorial concept of an apple pie slice with flaky pastry; not a photograph of Michele’s baking.

Crisco Sold a Whole Idea About the Modern Kitchen

Procter & Gamble introduced Crisco in 1911, using hydrogenation to turn cottonseed oil into a solid cooking fat. Hydrogenation changes the chemical structure of fats by adding hydrogen, altering how they behave, including their firmness. A fat that began as liquid oil could now do jobs associated with solid fats. Historian Helen Zoe Veit's research describes how the brand promoted industrial processing as a kind of purification, encouraging customers to trust the product and the company behind it. That's an interesting reversal of the way food is often sold now, when the suggestion that something has barely been touched can carry its own enormous advertising value.

The old promotional cookbook The Story of Crisco makes the approach especially obvious. Alongside recipes, it offers confident claims about purity and digestion, including the suggestion that children should eat Crisco foods to support good digestion. Those are historical sales claims, not advice I'm passing along. Still, I can't get over how enthusiastically a can of shortening was being recruited into the work of raising healthy children. The book supplied a whole kitchen's worth of uses, from biscuits to cakes and frying. Instead of asking a cook to work out where the new product belonged, it put the product directly into familiar meals and offered instructions.

Convenience Was a Real Part of the Appeal

I don't think we should read that history as evidence that every person who bought shortening had been fooled. A consistent cooking ingredient could be useful, and not having to process pork fat yourself could be useful too. The cookbook also promoted Crisco to Jewish cooks as a neutral fat that could be used with either meat or dairy foods under kosher rules. Pork lard couldn't fill that role. That's a practical difference in what an ingredient allows someone to cook, and it gets lost when we describe every change as a rejection of tradition. Different kitchens were solving different problems, sometimes with the very same can.

There's also the work involved in the older option. I enjoy learning how food is made, but I don't want to turn somebody else's hours at a stove into a charming decoration for my argument. Processing ingredients, cleaning equipment, and planning around what was available were jobs, even when the result was delicious. Being interested in an older skill doesn't require believing that everybody should have to do it. I can admire a carefully made lard crust and still understand why another cook might choose a packaged ingredient, or decide that this is absolutely not the afternoon they're taking on another kitchen project. Dinner already has a habit of becoming several projects wearing one name.

AI-generated editorial concept of an unlabeled jar of rendered lard beside an unbaked pie shell; not a product endorsement.

The Nutrition Story Doesn't Have a Surprise Winner

Lard contains a mixture of saturated and unsaturated fats, as other cooking fats do. Calling something animal fat doesn't mean every fatty acid in it is saturated, and calling something vegetable oil doesn't mean it contains none. That distinction is useful, but it doesn't turn lard into olive oil or establish that it should replace the liquid oils in your kitchen. The American Heart Association's 2026 dietary guidance continues to favor sources of unsaturated fat in place of saturated fat within an overall heart-healthy eating pattern. Its cooking-oil advice includes olive, canola, soybean, and other nontropical liquid oils as alternatives to solid fats such as lard.

Industrial trans fat is a different part of the story. Partially hydrogenated oils became a major source of it, and eating trans fat raises LDL cholesterol, which increases cardiovascular risk. In 2015, the FDA determined that partially hydrogenated oils were no longer generally recognized as safe for use in food, followed by a phased transition. That was an important correction to the food supply. It doesn't follow that all vegetable oils are partially hydrogenated, or that replacing an old shortening with lard is the same decision as choosing between lard and an ordinary liquid cooking oil. The ingredients and the comparison actually matter, inconvenient as that may be for an argument that would prefer a single villain.

We also shouldn't pretend the Crisco on a shelf today has the same formula as the product introduced in 1911. The current all-vegetable shortening lists soybean oil, fully hydrogenated palm oil, and palm oil among its ingredients. Fully hydrogenated and partially hydrogenated aren't interchangeable terms. I find it a little exhausting when a century of product changes gets folded into one photograph of a can, followed by a declaration about everything we're supposed to cook with. A good pastry ingredient and a good everyday choice for cardiovascular health are different questions. We can appreciate what lard does in a recipe without asking the pie crust to defend an entire diet.

For Some Cooks, There Wasn't a Disappearance

The phrase lard comeback needs a little care too, because it depends on whose kitchen we're talking about. Pati Jinich's recipe for tamales coloraditos includes lard as an option for the masa, alongside vegetable shortening or seasoned oil. King Arthur Baking publishes a Tender Pie Crust that calls for cold lard and also offers a butter substitution. Those are living recipes with choices built into them, not objects waiting to be rescued from a museum. I like that they're specific about the dish. We can talk about what a fat contributes to a particular dough without deciding that one recipe stands for all Mexican cooking, all American baking, or everybody's family history.

There's something rather strange about announcing that an ingredient has finally become respectable because a new audience is excited about it. If someone's been using it all along, the excitement probably tells us more about the newcomers than the food. That's my reaction to the language of rediscovery, rather than a claim that every family has followed the same path. Some people have affectionate associations with lard, others don't eat pork, and others simply prefer the way a different fat works. I'd rather leave room for all of them than produce a nostalgic kitchen where everybody's grandmother appears to have made the exact same biscuit.

Why Bakers Still Care About It

Fat changes what happens when flour meets water. Coating some of the flour limits water absorption and gluten development, helping a pastry feel tender rather than chewy. Leaving pieces of solid fat in the dough can also help separate it into layers as it's worked and baked. That's the basic idea behind a shortening fat, which is a broader baking term than the vegetable shortening sold in a can. Lard can do that job, and its appeal doesn't require a mysterious ingredient our ancestors understood but we've somehow forgotten. A lot of it comes down to the practical behavior of fat in dough, which is honestly interesting enough on its own.

King Arthur's lard crust uses both finely worked-in fat and larger pieces, along with cold water and a rest before rolling. The instructions make much more sense once you stop thinking of fat as something that's simply stirred into flour for richness. How you distribute it changes the result. I love the idea that two bowls with the same ingredients can lead to different crusts because of what happens under the cook's fingers, although I realize this is also how an innocent interest in pie becomes an entire afternoon spent worrying about the size of a lump. I'd start with a recipe designed for the fat I'm using, rather than assuming every solid fat can replace every other one without an adjustment.

AI-generated editorial concept of golden pork cracklings in a ceramic bowl beside a cast-iron pan.

And Yes, There Are Cracklings

Rendering can leave browned bits of solid material behind after much of the fat has been released. These are commonly called cracklings, although the name can cover different preparations, including versions with skin. An older USDA pork-processing bulletin describes cracklings browning during rendering and being separated from the fat. They're a useful reminder that the jar and the crisp pieces can come from the same process, rather than being unrelated products. I don't think we need to call that a miracle, but I do understand the appeal of getting something crunchy out of a job whose main purpose was collecting cooking fat.

This is also where I want to resist making every leftover into a lesson about how much better everybody used to live. Using something that would otherwise be discarded can be sensible and satisfying without turning a snack into a moral achievement. If you're interested in cooking with lard, you don't have to begin by rendering it yourself, buying an entire animal, or proving that you're committed enough to deserve a pie. A small amount from a food supplier, an appropriate recipe, and an understanding of what you're buying are a perfectly reasonable beginning. Food curiosity shouldn't need an entrance exam, particularly when there's already flour on everything.

What I'd Want to Know Before Buying It

I'd ask whether the product is rendered or still raw fat, what part of the pig it comes from, and whether the maker recommends it for sweet baking or savory cooking. I'd also read the ingredient list and follow the supplier's storage instructions, including refrigeration when required. A pale appearance doesn't tell us all of that, and neither does a jar with a charming label. Leaf describes the source of the fat, not a guarantee about the farm, the animal's life, or the finished product's flavor. Those are separate things to ask about, even if they tend to arrive together in the same enthusiastic sales paragraph.

The environmental and animal-welfare questions deserve their own answers as well. I like the idea of using edible parts of an animal that's already being raised for food, but I wouldn't take that as proof that any particular lard has a lower environmental impact than every plant oil. Nor would I treat words like local or heritage as a complete description of how a pig lived. If those things matter to you, it makes sense to ask what the supplier can actually tell you. And if you don't eat pork for religious, ethical, or personal reasons, there's no culinary obligation to start. A plant-based crust doesn't become less worthy because somebody else has developed an interest in rendering.

I'd Like to Let Lard Be an Ingredient Again

What keeps me interested in this story is the way the same qualities can acquire completely different meanings. A manufactured fat could once be sold through the promise of purity, while a jar of animal fat can now be sold through the promise of getting back to an earlier way of cooking. Both stories are asking us to connect a purchase with a bigger idea about how we ought to live. I can get embarassingly interested in the details of a food label, but I still want to know what the ingredient will actually do once it reaches the kitchen. The history is fascinating; it doesn't need to decide my entire personality.

Lard's place in American cooking changed as products, advertising, food production, and ideas about health changed around it. That change wasn't a single betrayal, and its continued use doesn't amount to proof that all the newer alternatives were wrong. For me, the most appealing reason to learn about it is much smaller and more delicious: understanding why a cook might choose it for a particular crust, a particular masa, or a particular savory dish. We can keep the interesting history, give credit to the cooks who've continued using it, and leave the grand declarations outside. I'd much rather have a conversation about how the pastry turned out, preferably while there's still some pastry left.

If I were making pie dough to see what the old recipes were getting at, I’d start with leaf lard and bake two little crusts, one with lard and one with butter. I’d break a piece from the edge of each first. That’s always the part I want to steal while the pie’s cooling.

Related Reads from the Archive

Sources

Michele Edington (formerly Michele Gargiulo)

Certified Sommelier, Certified Specialist of Wine, WSET Diploma student, writer & storyteller. I blend wine, science & curiosity to help you see the world as strange and beautiful as it truly is.

https://www.michelegargiulo.com/bio-page
Previous
Previous

Do Animals Know They’ll Die? What We Can Learn From Their Behavior

Next
Next

How Salt Changed History, From Ancient Mines to the Dinner Table