The Business Behind the Wine List, From a Sommelier Who’s Run One

I’ve spent more than a decade working with wine in restaurants, including running beverage programs. I love the part guests see: talking about a bottle, finding a pairing that makes dinner more interesting, and helping someone choose comfortably within their budget. I also know how much of the job happens before anybody sits down.

There are orders to place, invoices to check, bottles to count and staff to train. A wine that looks wonderful on a list still has to earn its place in the cellar. That’s why I get frustrated when a sommelier is treated as an optional bit of polish, with very little recognition of the business work behind the service. I’ve done that work, and I think it deserves a place in decisions about how a restaurant operates.

A bottle’s markup tells part of the story

When someone points to a wine’s wholesale cost and restaurant price, I understand the question. The difference can look enormous. It also helps to separate the cost of the bottle from the total cost of getting it into a guest’s glass.

Take a purely hypothetical bottle that costs a restaurant $20 and sells for $60. That leaves $40 after the wine’s purchase cost, a gross margin of about 66.7 percent before other expenses. It’s a three-times selling price relative to cost. The $40 still has work to do: payroll, rent, glassware, breakage, storage and the rest of the operation haven’t disappeared.

I wouldn’t use that example as a universal pricing formula. Restaurants have different expenses, service models and wine programs. The National Restaurant Association makes a similar distinction when discussing its operating data: individual restaurants need to understand their own costs, and its reported ratios are benchmarks for comparison rather than prescribed targets.

The point is to know what a sale contributes after the costs associated with it. A bottle with a large dollar margin can still spend years tying up cash on a shelf. A modestly priced wine that guests enjoy and reorder can do a very useful job. I want to understand both before deciding what belongs on the list.

The decisions behind the wine list

As a beverage director, I chose vendors, negotiated where I could, looked for value, watched inventory and worked with chefs on pairings. I also appeared on television and helped remind people that our restaurants existed. Those responsibilities required a different kind of attention from describing a wine at the table, but they were all part of supporting the program.

Buying is where a lot of that work begins. I want wines that fit the food, cover useful price points and make sense for the people coming in. A list can have a bottle I’m wildly excited about and still need an approachable option for somebody who simply wants a good glass with dinner. The guest’s budget is information I can use to help them.

Then there’s the stock we already own. An inventory count can reveal a wine that deserves another look, a case that has been overlooked or an ordering habit that needs to change. I’d rather put attention into those decisions than keep buying while old bottles sit unnoticed. The money committed to that cellar matters even when the cellar looks impressive.

By-the-glass wine brings another set of questions. How much are we pouring, how quickly does an open bottle sell, and what happens to what remains? Pricing and preservation need to fit actual demand. A wonderful glass pour that is repeatedly wasted can behave very differently on paper from the one I thought I was offering.

A good double-hinged wine key is one of the smallest things I carry onto the floor, and I reach for it all night. Opening the bottle is the visible moment. The decisions that bought, priced and stored it have already happened by then.

Education is part of running the program

I’ve watched wine education help a hesitant server become much more comfortable talking to guests. A short tasting can give somebody a reference they’ll remember more easily than a paragraph copied onto a study sheet. It also gives us time to work through ordinary questions before a guest is waiting for the answer.

One restaurant conversation with my husband has stayed with me: a server insisted that the white Sancerre being discussed wasn’t Sauvignon Blanc. White Sancerre is Sauvignon Blanc; red and rosé Sancerre are made from Pinot Noir. The distinction is specific and teachable. I’d like staff to have the opportunity to learn it, along with the confidence to check a fact when they’re unsure.

For me, selling well means listening well. If a guest wants a $50 bottle, I want them to feel as welcome as the table ordering something much more expensive. If there’s a wine a little above their original range that genuinely fits what they’ve described, I can explain it clearly and leave the choice with them. The goal is a dinner they feel good about, including the bill.

Training can support that kind of service. It should have time assigned to it, alongside the time needed to write the list, check stock and review performance. Those are substantial parts of the job. Expecting them to materialize around a full service schedule makes it harder for the program and the people running it.

Why the staffing question feels personal

Being let go from a sommelier role during the pandemic hurt. I’d invested time in the program, the staff and the producer relationships, and the loss felt like a judgment on work that I knew mattered. Dining rooms were closing and restaurants faced extraordinary decisions. My experience still left me with a lasting question about how much of a beverage professional’s contribution leadership could see.

I’m careful about turning that experience into a claim that every restaurant made the same choice. What I can speak to is the frustration of building something and feeling that a large part of the work went unrecognized. It’s one reason I want beverage professionals included when inventory, purchasing, pricing and staffing are discussed.

I also want to make that case without treating the kitchen or pastry team as the opposition. I worked in a bakery before culinary school, and I respect the skill and labor involved. A restaurant’s departments depend on one another. The sensible comparison is how the whole operation works, with each team’s costs and contribution understood properly.

A dedicated sommelier will make sense for certain restaurants, while another business may need a manager with beverage responsibility and a well-trained service team. The title alone guarantees very little. I’d look at the work that needs doing, who has the time and knowledge to do it, and how its results will be assessed.

The seat at the table I’m asking for

I want a beverage program to have clear responsibility, access to its own numbers and room for informed decisions. That includes talking honestly about what sells, what gets wasted, what sits too long and what guests ask for. It also includes recognizing when the person managing those details needs support.

I still love recommending the bottle that makes a meal click. I love the less photogenic work as well, because the list, the cellar and the service have to function together. My argument for taking sommeliers seriously rests on that combination of hospitality and business judgment. We should be able to discuss both in the same meeting.

That curiosity about wine and the people who drink it carries into my writing too. My Cruising with Wine project takes it into the wine regions along a trip, while Pairing Paws follows a more playful pairing direction. They’re different projects, but the pleasure of helping somebody find a wine they’ll enjoy runs through all of them.

Related reads

For another part of the service conversation, I’ve written about the science of wine-glass shapes. For a longer read, there’s The Sommelier’s Atlas of Taste and How to Build a Wine List.

Michele Edington (formerly Michele Gargiulo)

Certified Sommelier, Certified Specialist of Wine, WSET Diploma student, writer & storyteller. I blend wine, science & curiosity to help you see the world as strange and beautiful as it truly is.

https://www.michelegargiulo.com/bio-page
Previous
Previous

What the Brain’s “Willpower Muscle” Can Tell Us About Effort

Next
Next

Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards, and What I’d Tell My Cousin